Skip to main content

Protocol version 1.0

How we test video editing software

Every eligible editor must complete the same small project on the same test bench. A review cannot be indexed until its measurements, original evidence, reviewer record, and current official sources are complete.

Standard test bench

Hardware
MacBook Pro, Apple M1 Max, 10-core CPU, 64 GB memory
Operating system
macOS 26.5.2 (baseline recorded August 24, 2026)
Browser editors
Google Chrome 151.0.7922.170 at baseline
Desktop editors
Native macOS application

The exact environment and product version are frozen in each review record because operating systems, browsers, and software versions change.

The three-minute project

  1. 1.Import four owned or royalty-free clips into a three-minute 1080p project.
  2. 2.Trim and arrange the clips on a multitrack timeline.
  3. 3.Add one title, one transition, and one basic color adjustment.
  4. 4.Normalize or clean the project audio.
  5. 5.Generate captions from the same controlled 60-second transcript.
  6. 6.Export the completed project as 1080p H.264 when the tested plan permits it.

What we record

  • Setup time in minutes
  • Editing stability and crashes
  • Caption errors per 100 words
  • Export time in seconds
  • Output file size in megabytes
  • Maximum free export resolution
  • Watermark behavior
  • Free-plan or trial restrictions

Each published review also keeps original timeline, caption, and export evidence. Pros, cons, best-for guidance, not-for guidance, and alternatives must point back to those observations. Paid-only features may be described from current official documentation but are explicitly labeled “not hands-on tested.”

Plans and purchases

We test free plans and public trials only. We do not purchase subscriptions for this protocol. A free-plan limitation is reported as a limitation, not worked around, and a trial is never described as permanently free.

Sources and expiration

Pricing and free-plan sources expire after 90 days. Stable feature sources expire after 180 days. We prefer the product’s own pricing, help, release-note, and specification pages. Expired or missing sources make an otherwise eligible review fail the publication gate until they are rechecked.

Affiliate independence

Commercial relationship data is stored separately from test evidence. It cannot affect eligibility or ranking. Affiliate destinations use a sponsored link and are disclosed; products without a relationship link directly to their official site. Recommendations may favor non-affiliate products.

Updates and corrections

Search Console is reviewed weekly using 7-, 28-, and 90-day comparisons. Published facts are rechecked on their source cadence, and reviews are retested when a material version or plan change can alter the verdict. Correction requests follow the process on the About page.